*FOR THE GOVERNMENT. FOR THE PLATFORMS, IT’S A GIFT. THE SAME GOES FOR FLEET PARTNERS.
The government had two years to implement the Platform Work Directive. There are two weeks left until December 2nd. It is clear that it will not be implemented by this deadline. The implementing legislation is still caught up in various consultation processes. But Poland is not an exception; in the vast majority of EU countries, the Directive will not be implemented on time.
This situation proves there is no political will whatsoever to put an end to exploitation within these platforms. It is also an embarrassment for the state administration: failing to prepare a single, straightforward piece of legislation in two years? There is no excuse for this. It is simply a failure to act—especially given that the Minister of Labor, Agnieszka Dziemianowicz-Bąk, is a prominent figure in the ostensibly left-wing party “New Left” (Nowa Lewica). This party’s own slogan is: “Workers deserve to be treated with dignity.” Is this precisely why they have failed to implement the Directive over the last two years?
Naturally, this embarrassing state of affairs has consequences.
First, the exploitation of workers will continue. For the platforms and their fleet partners, maintaining the status quo—or implementing a version that changes very little—is excellent news. It means billions more in profit for them, while for us, it means more days spent working for a pittance, out in the rain and the freezing cold.
Second, we can also predict, more or less, what the European Commission will do: very little, if anything at all. During this year’s “Platforum,” representatives of the European Trade Union Confederation publicly stated that the European Commission intends to review the situation only three years after the December deadline. THREE YEARS!
In theory, once the implementation deadline (December 2) has passed, the Commission initiates proceedings by sending a formal notice to the government of the country in question. If the directive remains unimplemented following this notice, the Commission may refer the case to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU). However, for this to happen, there must be political will within the Commission—and, as we have learned, that will seems to have gone missing.
Thirdly, failure to implement a directive can result in financial penalties for a member state. In Poland’s case, such a penalty would amount to at least 3.84 million euros, though in practice, the sums are often higher. When Poland failed to implement the Whistleblower Protection Directive on time—resulting in a delay of two and a half years—a fine of 8.3 million euros was imposed. At first glance, this is a staggering sum; yet, no one in the government or parliament pays it out of their own pocket. It is covered by the Polish state budget (or, more precisely, it is deducted from the subsidies Poland receives from the EU budget). Consequently, even if the fine were to reach a billion euros, it would not affect the Minister of Labor personally—it would simply mean less money in the national budget. For the Polish state budget, 8.3 million euros carries the same relative weight as an expenditure of 0.17 groszy (yes! 0.17 GROSZY!) for a person earning 5,000 PLN.
And so, the only conclusion that comes to mind in this situation is the words of Dante: “Abandon all hope, ye who enter here.”
#zentrale_dyrektywa
And as we wrote above:
THERE ARE 14 DAYS LEFT TO IMPLEMENT THE DIRECTIVE ON PLATFORM WORK
